When it comes to managing your portfolio and growing your capital, I steer clear of mutual funds and instead invest in ETFs and individual securities. Here are the reasons why.
Three of the most common investment vehicles are mutual funds, ETFs and individual securities. However, when it comes to managing your portfolio and growing your capital, I steer clear of mutual funds and instead invest in ETFs and individual securities. Here are the reasons why.
1. Mutual funds are expensive
There are several fees associated with holding a mutual fund in your portfolio. First, there is the annual Management Fee, which is the fee charged by the mutual fund company for managing the fund. In addition, there is the annual Management Expense Ratio (MER), which incorporates the Management Fee plus additional costs associated with managing the fund. The MER on a Canadian Equity mutual fund is typically between 2.25% and 3%. For an International Equity mutual fund, it can be as high as 4%. The MER can be lower when held in a Fee-based account. Compare these numbers to the average administration fee of a Canadian Equity ETF, which is usually 0.25%-0.75%, or an International Equity ETF, which ranges from 0.25%-0.75% as well.
MERs aren’t the only fees mutual funds charge. In addition, mutual funds can be front-end loaded or back-end loaded.
A front-end load is a sales charge paid by you, at the time of purchase, to your mutual fund salesperson. It’s usually between 1% and 2%.
A back-end load is the fee charged to you when you redeem, or sell back, your units to the fund. Redeem your units within the first two years, and the fee will be between 5% or 6%. It drops to 0% to 2% only after 5 to 6 years. Basically, when you buy this kind of mutual fund, you’re locked into holding it unless you want to pay a fee. To drop that mutual fund from your portfolio and avoid having to pay a fee, your only option is to switch your capital to another mutual fund the company offers—however, it may be one that does not meet your criteria.
With ETFs and individual securities, there are no front-end or back-end loaded fees.
Oh, and there’s one more cost associated with a mutual fund: every time the fund’s portfolio manager makes a trade, the cost of the trade reduces your overall return. As your portfolio manager, I don’t do this. The buying and selling of ETFs or individual stocks is all included as part of my flat, monthly fee.
2. You can’t speak with a mutual fund portfolio manager
If you hold a mutual fund and would like to speak to the portfolio manager of that fund, typically you can’t. Generally speaking, they’re not available to the investing public. In contrast, I am a Portfolio Manager who is always available to speak with my clients and answer any questions you may have.
3. Mutual funds can be limiting
In most cases, a mutual fund has a mandate which influences what the fund’s portfolio managers can and cannot invest in. For example, a mutual fund’s mandate may be that it can only invest in the TSX 60. Such a mandate can really limit the scope of investment opportunities available to the portfolio manager. As an independent portfolio manager, I do not operate under such restrictions. Instead, I am free to evaluate any and all investment opportunities, and to make investment decisions accordingly.
4. Mutual funds trade differently
Mutual funds only trade once per day, after markets close at 4:00 PM. The price for a unit of each mutual fund is then readjusted and posted at around 6:00 PM. So, if you bought or sold your mutual fund units in the morning, you wouldn’t be able to learn at what price your trade settled at until 6:00 PM. As a result, theoretically, by the time your trade is executed, the price could be lower or higher than what it was in the morning. When you buy or sell an ETF or individual securities, you avoid this issue. The trade is completed while markets are open, and the price at which the trade was made is known immediately.
5. Mutual fund fees aren’t as transparent
With so many different percentages making up the fees that are part and parcel of owning a mutual fund, it’s not surprising that even regulators have been putting increasing pressure on operators of mutual funds to be more transparent. On July 15, 2016, they will have to be. That’s the day mutual fund companies have been mandated by the Ontario Securities Commission to start providing an annual report that breaks down the various fees and other compensation charges, in dollars.
Transparent fee reporting is something I have provided for my clients since I moved to fee based accounts. Every month on your statement you can see what my monthly fee is and, at the end of the year, HollisWealth provides a final summary of those fees.
As you can see, the reasons for avoiding mutual funds as an investment vehicle are quite compelling. At the end of the day, choosing between mutual funds or ETFs and individual securities is all about being prudent with your investment dollars and transparency.
This blog post was prepared solely by Herb Rempel who is a registered representative of HollisWealth® (a division of Scotia Capital Inc., a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund and the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada). The views and opinions, including any recommendations, expressed in this blog post are those of Herb Rempel alone and not those of HollisWealth.
® Registered trademark of The Bank of Nova Scotia, used under licence.